#BetterCallAmber

Insurance Made Personal, Just Like It Should Be.

A purple puzzle piece on a white background.

Insurance and Benefits for Indiana Families and Businesses

Whether you’re around the corner in Lafayette or down the road in Monticello, you’re never far from a helping hand.

At Insurance Solutions From Amber, we believe insurance should feel as personal as a handshake and as reliable as your best neighbor. Since 2011, we’ve been building relationships that matter—protecting homes, businesses, lives, and the moments in between. We proudly serve clients throughout Indiana, Tennessee, and Illinois. From your first car to your forever home, we’re here to help you make confident decisions every step of the way.

A woman is carrying a little girl on her shoulders in a field at sunset.

Homeowners

Protect your peace of mind with customized coverage that fits your home and your lifestyle.
A group of people are sitting around a table having a meeting.

Auto

Reliable protection on the road, with policies designed to keep you covered wherever life takes you.
A very old building with a cross on top of it

Business

Smart solutions for business owners—so you can focus on running your business, not worrying about risks.
Hear What Our Clients Have to Say
A row of black stars on a white background.

imgoodish

5 star shoutout to Tracy who provided wonderful customer service

Meg Uselton

Amber has always been quick to respond to my questions. I’ve never had an agent that looks out for me and finds me discounts. Wouldn’t want to go back to the website companies.

Chelsea Martin

We are very pleased with Amber's help through all of our insurance needs. Missie is also very quick at getting things taken care of and we couldn't be more appreciative of all their hard work!

Vernon Pratt

Recently shipped around for insurance after buying a house and moving to the area. The ladies at the agency are very timely and courteous. Haven't had to make a claim, but had very competitive rates and was a friendly agency.

Monica Buschman

Love the savings! Great customer service!

William Peake

Love these ladies!

Denise Hileman

Their office staff is awesome!

Ryan Fultz

3 years ago I moved all of my insurance to Amber and couldn't be happier. Not only did she save me money but she is available any time I need her.

Jeff Snethen

Great customer service.

naptown3127

Fast, attentive, and very organized. We couldn’t be happier with Amber and her service!

Jordan S

The best!

Dina Crouch

Very smooth change from one insurance company to this one. I highly recommend them for insurance. Awesome communication and customer service. Thank you!

Nate Bloyd

The biggest is not always the best! This group of ladies have a ton of experience, know their products and how to make policies work great for you, your home, your auto and/or your business!

Landon Thompson

I've been working with Amber for insurance for over 3 years and have had a wonderful experience. She's very quick in responding to phone calls and emails. Very personable and truly enjoys her job! Would highly recommend her to anyone looking for any type of insurance!

jason diehls

I've been insured with Amber and Missie for over 6 years. They're customer service is out of this world and they get stuff done! You would be crazy to not give them a chance to insure you!

Ski A

Best Best Best EVER!!!!!

Big A

Very Helpful and Friendly People!!

Jared Matthews

Amber and Mandy really helped me out with a great policy the fit my needs. I feel Mandy went out of her way on her day off helping me insure my two vehicles. I would definitely refer Insurance Solutions From Amber.

Hank Bolden

Saved me a bunch of money...

Amanda Brinegar

They are always there when you need them no matter the time of day! Love them!

Sam Gillock

Awesome Ladies! Easy to work with!
Why Work with Our Team?

Solutions Tailored to You.

A check mark in a square on a white background.

Local Roots, Real Relationships: We’re not just agents—we’re neighbors. Our Lafayette and Monticello offices are ready to serve you with a smile and real advice.

A check mark in a square on a white background.

Carrier Options That Work For You: We partner with trusted providers like Erie, Madison Mutual, Progressive, Bristol West, and Foremost to find the right fit.

A check mark in a square on a white background.

Tailored Guidance: No call centers here. When you need help, you know who to call. And yes—Better Call Amber.

Our Locations

WHERE TO FIND US

Lafayette Office

4826 Tazer Dr Suite C

Lafayette, IN 47905

765-429-7979

Monticello Office

137 South Main Street

Monticello, IN 47960
574-375-8979

Ready to Feel Confident About Your Coverage?

Let’s find the right policy for you. Whether it’s home, auto, business, or life—we’ve got you covered.
A man is kissing a woman on the cheek while holding a baby.
A white background with a few lines on it